Juno Temple
as Alice

Michael Angarano
as John

Alexis Bledel
as Payton

Billy Magnussen
as Arnie

Alia Shawkat
as Louise

Bobby Moynihan
as Chuck

Steve Park
as Dr. Ling

Ben Rappaport
as Ricky

Lucy Walters
as Mary

Jack McBrayer
as Joe

Debra Monk
as Trudy

Michael Delaney
as Mr. Tutor

Tara Copeland
as Mrs. Tutor

Thomas Middleditch
as Gilad

Bob McClure
as Yoel

Rebecca Darke
as Mollia

Ian Scott McGregor
as Interviewer

Travis Myers
as Bartender

Matt Walsh
as Antique Dealer

Danielle Kotch
as Eight Year Old

M.K. Walsh
as Female Reporter

Claudia Mason
as Donna

Cristin Milioti
as Brandi

Roland J. Walton
as BMW Dealer

Christopher Maggi
as Antiques Roadshow Attendee 1

Matthew Backer
as Antiques Roadshow Attendee 2

Yuen Byun
as Waxer

Adam Files
as Mr. Tutor's Lover

Kirk Roos
as Highway Patrolman

Christopher Jon Gombos
as Cowboy (uncredited)

William Todd Levinson
as Reception Attendee (uncredited)

Harry L. Seddon
as Antique Collector (uncredited)